Page 1 of 1

Froyalan

Posted: Fri Nov 23, 2007 12:12 pm
by Aurangzeb Khan
Bloody modernist revivionist vandals...

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Fri Nov 23, 2007 1:37 pm
by Jonas
The name is gone... :cry

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Fri Nov 23, 2007 1:48 pm
by Aurangzeb Khan
Long Live the Elwynnese Resistance!

Elwynn steigt wieder!

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Fri Nov 23, 2007 10:58 pm
by Ari Rahikkala
Straylight will help if you first rename the three Lesser Zjandarias to something more palatable. :p

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Sat Nov 24, 2007 7:15 am
by Harald of Froyalan
What about Lesser Straylight? ;-)

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Sat Nov 24, 2007 10:41 am
by Aurangzeb Khan
I'm willing to conceed on renaming the LZ to Ardashire seeing as it might be considered as being the lesser evil compared to the bastardisation of Elwynn into Froyalan.

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 12:00 am
by Kaiser Mors V
it's not revisionism.. it's de-warcraftism...

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 12:53 am
by Andreas the Wise
The Khan of Vijayanagara wrote:I'm willing to conceed on renaming the LZ to Ardashire seeing as it might be considered as being the lesser evil compared to the bastardisation of Elwynn into Froyalan.
Fight to the death for it then ... lots of people want a civil war ...

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 4:27 am
by Harald of Froyalan
Kaiser Mors V wrote:it's not revisionism.. it's de-warcraftism...
It indeed is.

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 12:17 pm
by Aurangzeb Khan
Warcraft, or indeed Erik's original intentions when naming the place, are in large part irrelevant to this - Elwynn has been Elwynn for so long that the name has acquired in the context of Shireroth and indeed Micras a meaning that is entirely of its own and indeed a history that is longer and a cultural significance that is greater than most micronational communities in existance today.

Elwynn has a identity within the context of micronational simulation upon which it deserves to be praised and defended.

Elwynn is the land defined indeed framed by the mighty river of that name, which links Shirekeep to the world, the river along which so many people of so many nations have come to bask in the glory of the capital of this fine Imperial Republic. The mighty Elwynn, both in its Eastern and Western branches as well as their great confluence just east of Shirekeep, from where the greatest river flows to the sea is to Shireroth what the Nile is to Egypt, it is the river that is the beating heart of this civilisation, surely it is not untoward that this great river should lend its name to this between the two rivers, this Mesopotamia.

Without Elwynn, the great deity upon whom the doom of so many rested, the great cycle of the Treesian Apocalypse would never have been fulfilled and Eoin would have remained forever trapped in this realm, doubtless as just another funky wombat.

Elwynn the abode of elves and men in ancient times and the seat of continual wars between them even unto recent times. It has been both the master and the subject of strange and mysterious Hyperborea. It is home to diaspora populations of Menelmacari, Babkhans and the men of Hurmu. Each would doubtless give their own name to this land if they could but an equilibrium of a sort, punctuated by violence, ownfalls and uprisings perhaps, has existed ever since the downfall of Duchess Mari Greenwood in what must be, relatively speaking, be considered the ancient past - as such Elwynn has given good satisfaction as a starting point on a common identity for all races, from which the reforms of Ric Lyon yielded a balanced multi-cultural polity which ought to be respected and honoured.

It would be appreciated if the Duke of Elwynn himself were to offer a fuller justification for this change.

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Thu Nov 29, 2007 9:58 pm
by Andreas the Wise
He has a point. (I respect people who talk lovingly and historically about land). Sure, de-warcraft the names that were just there and have no development. But the developed ones are, by their nature, now so Shirithian it's no longer warcraft, really ...

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Mon Dec 03, 2007 3:47 am
by Scott of Hyperborea
Think of your history, Erik. Remember Aeronesia? "Aeronesia" was a much better name than "Jasonia" in every respect: it sounded better, it looked cooler, it was more serious, it was more fitting. It's just that the country we were trying to apply it to happened to be named "Jasonia", and that turned out to not be something we can change.

Let me also say this. You know how, if you're a really fast typer, you have a lot of words in muscle memory? For example, when I was writing biology reports in college, whenever I tried to type "micron" I would end up typing "micronation" and have to delete the "ation" part later? Well, my mother's name is Ellyn. And every time I try to type her name into a form or a letter or something, I always end up typing "Elwynn". That's how serious this whole ducal name thing is - in my subconscious mind, it trumps the name of my own mother. Now, granted, I have a whole lot more reasons to type "Elwynn" than "Ellyn" seeing as I usually refer to my mother as "Mom" except on formal documents, but the point stands.

Re: Froyalan

Posted: Mon Dec 03, 2007 12:47 pm
by Kaiser Mors V
hmmmm. in the end I left it up to the Duke. I gave my oppinions, and encouraged certain ideas.. but I never officially decreed a name change, or officially gave an order on the matter. If he desired to change it back. The Duke could. And I would not block the action.


To be fair... I am also rather used to writing it....

Why does this remind me of the fight about the name of Musica...?